2-in-1: Personification & Pumpkin-Carving (+juggling) Winners Parody
by tate

Comment:
Awesome shot, really looks like that bottle opener is juggling, I am going to look this up after the challenge to see how you did this, hope you put down a good description in the "photographers comments". 9 from me.

Lunch at Manny's
by MichaelC

Comment:
I think I would have liked this better with softer lighting, the harsh lighting isn´t really flattering to her even her seemingly flawless skin and the WB is a bit too cool for my taste but everything else is pretty good in this shot, you landed a 7 from me.

Bodhisattva Will Nose You Out!
by smyk

Comment:
Scaaaaaaaaary! Must be awful for you to shake hands with fishworkers :) But seriously, well done and a very cool effect, I gave it an 8.

Goldfishy
by oOWonderBreadOo

Comment:
Nice, having that bracelet or whatever around the glass really adds to it, would be even better if the bracelet in a different coulour than the backround but it works also nicely like it is.

Imagineer's "Pride of London" Remake
by AlexSaberi

Comment:
I am going to throw a wild guess and say that this is Alexsabreris shot, I know you are in this challenge and I know you are doing well :) Anyway, love the shot, it is as good as the original and possibly even better but I can´t really give it a 10 because it is a remake that doesn´t really add anything to the original so I´ll give you a 9, happy with that? :)

Extinguished but not Forgotten
by riot

Comment:
Cool, I love the glow on the matches, makes them seem very sinister :) 8 from me.

Plasmic II
by marbo

Comment:
Nice, could work in "abstract macro" too if you have time for a reshoot.

Touched by the Moonlight
by naomik

Comment:
Sorry but I think this shot is too dark to rate fairly.

Tribute to Gaurawa for 'Five'
by nikuser

Comment:
Nicely done but somehow his has more soul, more mystery, can´t put my finger on it but it´s probably the lighting. Anyway, not bad at all, well done on the technicals.

Enchanted Falls
by elsapo

Comment:
Congrats on yet another ribbon dude, you are definately one of the most promising photographers here. Must say that this result surprised me, don´t get me wrong, this is hardly a bad shot but just too dark for my taste and very ordinary, postcard like so I gave it a 6, a rating that means "above average and a pretty good shot" for me :)