steps.jpg
by xtine

Comment:
This one is AWESOME! Went straight to my favorites and not a thing I would change about it. Reminds me of Ed´s work, (e301), nice work!

The Whangie.jpg
by xtine

Comment:
This one is pretty cool, I like your b&w conversion style, it is very nice and contrasty. This is however a shot I think I might have preferred in color, with the girl in some bright colored clothes contrasting against the dark monotone rocks but it works in b/w.

chrysalis small.jpg
by xtine

Comment:
Nice shot, I like the tones in it. It´s a bit of a neck twister though as you say and that is probably the only thing I dislike about it, nice work, especially on the lighting, I love the lighting!

Vulcan - Roman God of Fire
by Rikki

Comment:
Sheesh, don´t really feel qualified to comment as you kicked my ass in this challenge but you wanted a comment so here it goes.

You specifically asked about the hand. I don´t see what bothers you so much, I think it looks pretty cool and "in sync" with the rest of the shot. However, if you mean you wanted more light on it, I would just suggest just that, light it with a monolight and make sure using a red/yellow filter of some sort as the light from the monolight would differ vastly from the lighting from the flames. If you were to do that, lighting it from above would be my suggestion, I like that the part that turns away from the flame is in shadow. Nice work my friend, 6.5+ and could easily have gone higher too.

To the Bat Sub
by Kronus

Comment:
Gotta agree with jaded_youth, it´s hard to make out what this is, this photo is a bit dark, needed to be some lighting down the drain too :) Nice as an abstract but I am not really a fan of abstract so the subject isn´t really appealing to me. Nicely composed though, I like the angle it´s shot from.

by Canadian_eh

Comment:
This one I like much better, the same goes for techical issues, I like that. However the composition and expression of the cat are much better, I don´t think there is much you can do to improve this save maybe watch out for blown highlights on his throat. LOVE the dof, nice work.

by Canadian_eh

Comment:
This is pretty nice, well done technically, I like the sharpness and lighting. However, is a bit too cramped compositionally for my taste, would have either liked an even more up close shot where you fill the frame with just one eye for example or to back up.

The Past
by Djabordjabor

Comment:
Congrats dude, I think you´ll ribbon before soon :)

reflections of the past
by Rikki

Comment:
Aw crap! You completely destroyed me! Next time there is an Architecture challenge I am coming over buddy, Icelandair flies directly to San Fran so beware! :)

Yesterday´s Architecture
by Structor

Comment:
Congrats dude, now all you need is a blue ribbon and a 4th honorable mention and you got a "full house", I have faith that you will pull it off, sooner than later :)