private
by tcmartin

Comment:
To be honest I gave this a 5 when I scored this challenge. 5 from me means for me average, neither good nor bad and I don´t really connect to the shot. For me personally this got lost in a landslide of good images and I didn´t really connect to this image. I think it´s the fact that the image is faceless and no eyes that doesn´t do it for me.

pods
by tcmartin

Comment:
Nice shot, well lit. Think this shot got a little bit of did not meet the challenge votes, scored lower than I would have thought. I can understand that though even though I would have voted as it met the challenge, traditionally still life is of inanimate objects and you photographed something that either is or was very recently alive. Anyway, nice shot, well composed and well lit, nice work technically speaking.

Eleanor Rigby - Waits at the Window Wearing a Face that She Keeps in a Jar by the Door
by Aeroglyphics

Comment:
Nice shot and congrats on your new top score, won´t be long till you improve it though if I am not mistaken, you seem to be on the way to getting the hang on what scores well here and I wouldn´t be surprised to see good stuff rom you in the future.

I like the shot, well lit and technically well done, only thing I really dislike is the BLACK backround around the girl, think I would have preferred it if there was something visible there but still dark, like the innards of the hut (or whatever is behind her). Nice work, would probably have given it a 7 in the challenge.

The Whangie colour3.jpg
by xtine

Comment:
Yup, I like this one better too, now both the composition and coloring draw the eye to the girl :)

Fish in Flight
by RyShu

Comment:
WOW! LOVE this shot, it´s friggin awesome, the tones are nice. Only to nitpick, I would have liked this shot more (if possible) without the two people in the foreground, with just the three of them standing there but I still gave this a 10 and added it to my favorites, nice work!

This Wall Can Talk
by GuGi

Comment:
Yeah, and looks like it needs to blow it´s nose too :)

Even when all seemd dark, love found it's way
by Krisby

Comment:
Gotta watch those highlights in the waterfall, they bug me a lot. Also the composition is a bit "cramped", I would have liked this shot better with some more space around the couple but just a little, just maybe 5% more under their feet and behind the dude. Anyway, aside from that, pretty nice, 6 from me.

Beware of the monster
by Djabordjabor

Comment:
Not really caring for the motion blur, well, it would work on the boy but on the woman, not so much. Nice idea though, don´t think I would have climbed NAKED into a garbage bin for DPC though, hehe :) 6 from me.

The Alliance
by missinseattle

Comment:
I wish this shot was more crystal clear and sharp, looks a bit "fuzzy" and I don´t like that about it.

I'm Leaving On a Jet Plane
by gliphix

Comment:
Nice shot, I like the mood in it and composition, got a 7 from me.