Afternoon Cue in Blue
by 77DX

Comment:
This is an absolutely beautiful shot, but I don't see how it meets the challenge. I know the guidelines were vague and there's been some dispute about how they shold be interpreted, so I'm just trying to be fair and consistent. But your photograph is beautiful.

FINISH LINE
by Rando D300

Comment:
Definitely one of the best photos in this challenge :-)

Waiting for an order
by hanlomba

Comment:
What great expressions on the faces you've captured here!

Framing your Life
by soccerrocker1989

Comment:
Overall, I really like this photo. It has a lot of character. But I can't discern what is being framed by the window. I've come back several times yesterday and today to get a fresh look, but just can't see it. Thus, in my humble opinion, it did not meet the challenge as I understood it. I do think it's a great photo, tho.

Living Waters
by Andrewat

Comment:
Beautiful photograph. I don't think it fits the challenge as I understand it. I know there's some disagreement about the guidelines. I'm trying to be fair and consistent ;-)

Clear Blue Sky
by JudeLeo

Comment:
This photo, at least to me, is a beautiful example of depth of field, or perspective, or landscape. But as I understand the challenge, I can't make it fit. I know there's some disagreement on that -- but I am trying to be fair and consistent. I do like the photo, tho.

Yellow
by arngrimur

Comment:
Very nice! and it actually fits the challenge as I understand it!

Old Country
by kirtiebu

Comment:
This definitely fits the challenge as I understand it, but it appears a little out of focus to me. I would have marked it higher if either the framing or the background had been more in focus.

Twilight
by ddmckinney1954

Comment:
I love the colors of this photograph, and think it is very good. We all seem to be struggling a little with the guidelines for this challenge, and I'm trying very hard to be fair. I don't believe the photo meets the challenge guidelines, at least not as I understand them. But it is beautiful.

mist
by ursula

Comment:
I think this is a beautiful photograph. It seems we are all struggling a little with the guidelines for this challenge, and I am trying very hard to be fair. Even tho I really like the photo, I don't think it fits the challenge guidelines as I understand them.