Selfportrait
by Dvan

Comment:
I hesitate to make comments since I am obviously not an expert, but here goes: the photo meets the challenge and is in excellent focus. I would have voted it higher if it had been cropped more off the left side so that the part of that eye is not seen. I did up the score anyway on my third time through the photos.

~ Leveled beyond the roof ~
by t_korecki

Comment:
I'm glad I had time to come back and reconsider this photo. I like it better on this monitor and have upped my original score. Hope it helps ;-)

Colorful Lights
by dphillips

Comment:
I hesitate to make comments since I am obviously not an expert, but here goes: the photo meets the challenge and is in good focus. It is just my opinion that a photo should be able to "stand alone" apart from the challenge (not sure that makes sense, in other words, it should be a good subject even if you don't know what challenge it was entered into). I felt that was where this photo was a little weak -- I couldn't see it having meaning apart from the challenge.

Not Madonna's Bra !
by Tuckersmom

Comment:
I hesitate to make comments since I am obviously not an expert, but here goes: the photo meets the challenge and is in good focus. It is just my opinion that a photo should be able to "stand alone" apart from the challenge (not sure that makes sense, in other words, it should be a good subject even if you don't know what challenge it was entered into). I felt that was where this photo was a little weak -- I couldn't see it having meaning apart from the challenge.

Camera Bag
by minime850

Comment:
I hesitate to make comments since I am obviously not an expert, but here goes: the photo meets the challenge and is in good focus. It is just my opinion that a photo should be able to "stand alone" apart from the challenge (not sure that makes sense, in other words, it should be a good subject even if you don't know what challenge it was entered into). I felt that was where this photo was a little weak -- I couldn't see it having meaning apart from the challenge.

"LuC" a dorsal view
by AltPro

Comment:
I hesitate to make comments since I am obviously not an expert, but here goes: the photo meets the challenge and is in good focus. It is just my opinion that a photo should be able to "stand alone" apart from the challenge (not sure that makes sense, in other words, it should be a good subject even if you don't know what challenge it was entered into). I felt that was where this photo was a little weak -- I couldn't see it having meaning apart from the challenge.

Just a green eye
by andrerusso

Comment:
I hesitate to make comments since I am obviously not an expert, but here goes: the eye is certainly lovely, but a tad out of focus. That will probably hurt it in the voting.

Humpy fluke
by chrism23

Comment:
I hesitate to make comments since I am obviously not an expert, but here goes: I thought the subject was excellent, but slightly out of focus. I can only imagine how difficult it would be to get this in sharp focus!

Part of me
by bobdaveant

Comment:
This photo is so appealing to me -- I gave it a "9" -- hope you do well in the final analysis.

A Puzzling View.
by Artyste

Comment:
This was my favorite photo of the challenge and my only "10" -- I hope you explain how you did it after the challenge.