Newton's Apple
by charliebaker

Comment:
I don't know if you intended all the noise, but it detracts from an otherwise nice idea. 5

untitled
by ssengupta

Comment:
I don't know what this is, or if it's innovative or not but for me, there is no focal point to it. It seems like it would be a background for something else. The colors are good and focus seems to be on target (I think). I don't like the red border at all, it pulls my eyes right to it and (IMO) doesn't add anything to the image. After all that, I will score this a 7 for taking chances.

Gear
by Halim

Comment:

Originally posted by Halim: mr gatorguy...thanks for the concern...who said i thought that this was "one"?...i can see that this is "I"...but what i didn't see is a helpfull comment ur comment was just "I"...which made me wondering...what does it means...so i left u that notice ...and i realy don't mind if any one left me a "1" cuase that is up to ur taste and i have nothing to do with it...hope every thing is clear now Mr. ....regards..and thank u again

Fair enough, it was just a misunderstanding all the way around.

Gear
by Halim

Comment:
My comment in the during the challenge is not a 1 (notice the difference?). I think I started to leave a comment and then for whatever reason, didn't. I actually gave you a five on this image. That said, I think it was in poor taste for you to ramble on like that about score you "thought" I gave you, even if it was a 1.

Message edited by author 2005-01-10 08:47:48.

Tokyo fish market
by blanceric

Comment:
This is a good image technically, but emotively, it doesn't really do it for me. 5

"I see you!"
by parrothead

Comment:
I love this. For some reason, I look at this a a 50's look comes to mind. The black and white conversion is good, just the right contrast. I think it could be just a little sharper in the face. 8

Friends
by rmtm333

Comment:
Wonderful emotive image. If anything, I would crop a little more from the left, but that's just one opinion. 8

A visit from the neighbor's children
by camelotnorth

Comment:
This is pretty small, and I'm sure you've heard that a lot by now. Other than that, it doesn't look very candid to me as they obviously know the camera is there.

Life's Simple Pleasures
by Brad

Comment:
Returning for comments. The expressions you captured are terrific, I am bumping from 8 to 9

Weary Little Tourist
by SandyP

Comment:
I think this is great. My only nit is that on my calibrated monitor, it has a slight blue tint. Not penalizing you though. 9