Lullaby Lane
by Shakey

Comment:
Nice image, very emotive. I don't know that I would call these road signs though.

'Warning' Strange Man Having Trouble With Umbrella in Road Ahead
by daztaz

Comment:
Good job! You are going to lose a lot of point because of picture size though.

Kitty Nose with Appel
by charliebaker

Comment:
Road signs?? What were you thinking??

1874 ~ 2004
by glad2badad

Comment:
I like your choice of the old decaying wood surface - this little detail makes the shot for me. 9

Boats
by biggood53

Comment:
maybe I don't know boats very well, but I don't get the old and new part here. I see large and small.... Benefit of doubt = 5

miners
by vfischer

Comment:
I'm sure with your inside knowledge, there is old and new here, but it just doesn't come through to me. Other than that, the photo is very beautiful.

Picture of the Past
by eaemthomas

Comment:
I think the contrast of old and new is good but to be blunt, a little uninteresting. I think your choice of background is too distracting with all the textures. Maybe if you have moved the cameras away and used a shallow DOF to blur it, it would have been better. As it is, it reflects the flash in a distracting way. I like that you've placed the film canisters around the foreground for interest, but shouldn't the ones in front of the Spartus have been 120's [ not knocking you for that ;) ]. I'm giving this image a 5.

Nostalgia
by fplouffe

Comment:
Good shot, right on the challenge. My only nit is all the dust particles. 7

Steam Vs Electric
by Node

Comment:
Good catch

Grandfather's Voigtlander vs Grandson's Nikon
by nsmith

Comment:
The old and new part is fine. The compostion is a little disconnected for me. It appears as if you are trying to keep them separate via the use of the frame, but for me the frame is a distracting element.