Soil rich in calcium carbonate and clay casts the water a cerulean blue, Walloon Lake!
by wdamman

Comment:
I like the fact that you used the rule of thirds here, it works well. Your image to me just seems to be over post-processed and this is noticeable in the flowers in the foreground. Just my opinion

The Drink
by Jules1x

Comment:
Nice depiction of the drinkable water as opposed to the non-drinkable water. The colours are good and nice sun flare.

Divination on the waves
by lei_73

Comment:
Unfortunately due to the angle of which the image was taken, the image seems a little flat. Yes, it is "liquid", but I find that something more creative could have been entered.

blood from a stone
by mefnj

Comment:
I love your idea, thinking out of the box! Cant find anything negative to comment on your entry!

Spray & Wash
by Kelli

Comment:
This challenge allows for advanced editing, but besides that, I feel that this seems more like a family holiday photo and sure whether the purists would resist the temptation to scrutinize this image in greater depth as to the creative worthiness of this image. The colours are very muted and could have been more bold and a better DOF could've got rid of the distracting background

Fall harvest
by Neat

Comment:
This could've been entered for the "Summertime meals" instead. I'm not convinced that , although you are trying to portray that soup is a winter type dish, that the leaves add any value to the image. Just my opinion

Liquid Lunch
by JakeKurdsjuk

Comment:
A great capture of the moment. This is a challenge with advanced editing allowed, but you could have tried this image with a little less harsh light, the colour of the stem of the glass is unfortunately lost and could have added value to the overall image.

After The Day is Done Liquid
by westford

Comment:
Pity that the glass is very tightly cropped at the bottom. I understand that you may have wanted to eliminate what the glass was standing on, but if you used the correct surface, you could have gotten away with having to crop it out this way. One has to very careful when using horizontal lines with another subject in the forefront, one can see that the glass is tilted slightly. Still a great image.

Liquid Courage
by Budya

Comment:
Great image, idea and clarity. I do find however that the rule of thirds could have improved this image a little more. It is very centred. Still a great capture with wonderful colours! :)

Geyser
by dtremain

Comment:
With the colour of the skies, the liquid seems to get lost amongst it. This challenge open for advanced editing, so I'm sure that you could have done something to improve on the colours or could have tried to take the image at a different time of the day, if possible. If it is a geyser erupting, I can understand that one cannot change or predict what and when they erupt.