my father
by da-answer

Comment:
I think this photo would have been better for the outside looking in challenge.

Cow in Field at Night
by pique_moi

Comment:
hahahahaha the contraversial photo from the forums. i Like it.

Serenity Under Chaos
by grandmarginal

Comment:
I like the B&W and couldn't help wonder what his would look like inverted. Well done.

Souls Aloft
by justine

Comment:
I like it. Have you considered the invert tool in photoshop??? I adds a freaky feel to it when inverted.

The Perfect Storm #3
by dsidwell

Comment:
wow beautiful shot. The only thing that bothers me about them is the levelness. Fantastic shots.

Doorway to Darkness
by eostyles

Comment:
A very well composed shot with excelent clarity. I like the tone of the sky and think it adds to the photo by giving it a creepy or errie feeling. I like the dark spots in it as well such as the door and find it leaves more to the imagination. I do find the brush to be a little distracting but aside from doing some landscaping before you took the photo there is nothing you could do about it. Perhaps it would have done better in B&W? altho I really think color was the way to go. I do think that a lot of people underrated your photo and I believe that is due to so many entries. Hope this helps bit and good luck in the future challenges.

Abandoned ... Or Is It ?
by Coley

Comment:
Would have scored a <9> had it been level. I like the grainyness and the B7W conversion and the faintness of the person in the photo. I think it adds to the photo and raises the bar in this challenge. well done and good luck.

Still..........A beautiful view remains
by jaaad

Comment:
Excellent colors and clarity but to me this photo says ruins not abandoned and that would say to me that it doesn't fit the challenge very well. The size of the image is a little smal as well. Good luck in this chalenge.

Please Lock Gate When Leaving
by GeneralE

Comment:
Nothing about this photo would suggest abandoned building to me. It suffers size and clarity issues probably due to the resize of the image. Perhaps a better subject would have made for a better photo for this challenge. Good luck in this challenge.

Once Upon a Dog
by gotrond

Comment:
I'm not really sure I understand the photo for this challenge. I don't see any building or anything of that nature. I also find the blurr to be distracting. Good luck in this challenge.