Vancouver
by GolferDDS

Comment:
Nice variation on the main theme, slightly let down by the fact this image is slanting to the right.noticably. It seems as though the ripples led you astray as they seem straight to the edge. Nice colour. good focus.

The City of Melbourne
by Kel73

Comment:
Just disimilar enough from the other entries to stand out.
Nice work on focus and colour. Good control of intrest with a sky that ads to the overall effect. A minor niggle is the dark area to the left and bottom left which detracts fromt the whole, a little creative crop might increase impact.

Hong Kong Light Display
by bcenu

Comment:
There are so many similar entries to this challenge that you have to stand out to be noticed, and this does. Nice lines with the V shape cupping the city. well focused and not oversaturated. Good camera work.

The Hot Corner
by GeneralE

Comment:
Looks like a high ISO 800 or so . there is a grainyness to this picture that spoils the overall effect, Nice concept, but a little lacking in intrest for me.

Cavallo rosso
by snaffles

Comment:
You have perfectly captured this jump, there is movement, drama, intrest and a perfect controll of focus and depth.
Some may say the subject should have been more central, do not listen, the siting gives motion to the overall.
There is a little something just above the horses tail, an area I initially thought was blurred due to depth of field focus, but it may be camera or proccessing. It is the ONLY thing I found fault with in this image

Cohoes Cascade
by Neil

Comment:
HDR?
Oversharpened?
Nice image which has been proccessed to the point where it no longer looks like a photograph, more a painting. If this is the result you were after then well done. You can see that the origional image (s) was well focused and lovely control of depth.
I dont know, it is striking. good luck in the challenge

Cantarella
by mrbig65

Comment:
A lovely Autumnal feel to this image, I particularly like the use of 16/9. despite the well focused and lovely judjed saturation I think this image is too uniform. Funny to say with so much texture I know, but a basket, or a knife, something else to break up the uniformity would punch out the interest.
for all that I love this image.

Classic Chrome
by essay

Comment:
Nice, well judged tone use.
There is a loss of focus towards the rear of the greyhound, personaly I would have tried to get the whole of the hood ornament in focus, I know this is a bit of extra work but it does pay off.
I love the concept and use of sepia.

Classic Cars and Clouds
by giantmike

Comment:
Lovely control of the B/W medium, nice crisp focus and depth
there seems to be either two ariels or a couple of lines just comming up from the second car back which catch the eye a bit too much and irritate. A bit of cloning out might have helped here. otherwise lovely picture

Its Good To Be Home Again
by GolferDDS

Comment:
I like this, the control, focus, and clarity are spot on.
Personally I would have called it "are we home yet?" to capture the cats look. but eveything is a choice. Nice picture best of luck in the challenge