Size is Everything
by glad2badad

Comment:
OMG... this is beyond funny!
I see the proportion in this shot... but... this is just hilarious!
Maybe I just need to get my mind out of the gutter.
I love this!
It shows great proportion and is comedic at the same time!
Not to mention, the focus is great, the lighting seems good... everything seems in order in this shot.

I'm giving this a 10!

perfectly proportioned
by Giles

Comment:
I'm all for boudoir photography...
However, this is not "my" idea of perfectly proportioned. A little more "junk in that trunk" and I would say yes.

But... being said...
I love the crop on this shot. Great processing. Nice classic coloring. Her skin seems a tad too soft... but, great take on proportion!

Still giving this an 8

"To Have and Have Not"
by tvsometime

Comment:
Love the story in this photo. Take proportion to a different level. The old lady in the back seems to be a little overexposed... but nice candid shot.

Small Gains
by MinsoPhoto

Comment:
Love the processing here.
Great lighting.
Nice title.
Tells a wonderful story. Great job, love all the portraiture you've been doing.

Sign of the Iron Horizon
by crowis

Comment:
Too much PPing in this image. The horizon has a strange glow/halo to it. The picture is too dark overall, for my liking.
I'm thinking you were trying to show a lack of proportion in this shot?

Will come back to vote.

Bar Graph
by GeneralE

Comment:
I like the idea here.
It seems a little overexposed on the left, and I'm not feeling the darkness of the tops of the tools.
It looks like it's OOF as well? Perhaps a handheld shot with some camera shake?

I do think it's a great concept, and I like the title...
I feel with a few adjustments, this shot could do well.

Coming back to vote

A Sense of Proportion
by vawendy

Comment:
Really like this silhouette shot! Wonderful portrayal of proportion.
My only criticism about this is the brightness (overexposure?) to the left of the frame on the water.
Other than that... It's a nice shot.
Will come back to vote.

Eye
by mshonak

Comment:
Cute shot to portray proportion.
It looks a little snapshot-ish to me...
I'm not feeling the dark shadow underneath the child's chin, along with the shadow under her arm. Judging by the bright white spot on the magnifying glass, and the shadows, I would say the flash was used, unless she was near an extremely bright light?
Perhaps different lighting would have enhanced the quality of this photo?

Also, it seems that the white balance is a tad off.

On the plus side... I do like how the magnified eye is a little brighter than the rest of the photo... it gives it a "pop"
And the kid is definitely cute. Adorable facial expression!

Overall, I think with a few minor adjustments, this photo could really do well! :)

Catch of the Day
by mrchhas

Comment:
HAHAHA!
I love this shot.

Great way of showing proportion.

I think you went a touch heavy on the processing...
but overall a good shot!

Coming back to vote.

Colossal Heights
by giantmike

Comment:
Really enjoy this shot.
Beautiful black and white!

This is a great portrayal of proportion. The little boy walking amongst the gigantic trees!!!
Great processing.

Since the little boy is the main subject (against the trees) I think I would have straightened the photo a touch to align him properly against the ground. But other than that... I think this turned out beautifully!

One of my highest rated in the challenge (so far). I'm giving this a 9