rising rings
by claudiadf

Comment:
I'm not sure what this is. Your title isn't helping me much here... After looking at this many, many times I'm thinking the rings may be onions...? Please email me with more information and I'll adjust your score accordingly.

Aroma is inspired by nature
by ramevi

Comment:
Interesting crop here. I like it. I feel that the colors could be adjusted a bit to make them more vibrant. Really nice shot. I gave this a 7.

Fresh Bread Baked Daily (since 1903)
by mariomel

Comment:
Since I don't know french, I wouldn't have known by looking at this that this is a bakery. I'm assuming "Boulangerie" means bakery or something similar. I'm glad your title mentioned bread because I probably would've scored this as a 7 for possibly "not meeting the challenge" as a building doesn't really tell me anything about scents. :-) Instead, I gave this a 10. This has a very nice feel to it. Love that this is a night-time shot. The glowing trees and well lit sign work well. Love the curvy railing too. Super job. ;-)

The season's scents
by Bela45

Comment:
I like the layout and placement of the cookies and things. This is a very nice photo. I do see some neon-blue color around the right of the cinnamon sticks and cloves (?) that doesn't seem to belong, though. The upper left of the photo seems perfectly lit but as you go down and to the right it worsens. It gets darker and darker and the blue colors show up more.

Nice job, though. I gave this an 8.

Winter Aromas
by adine

Comment:
Great job here! I love the perspective/crop of this. I like all of the details; the cocoa, mittens, cookie and scarf. I would have liked to see a bit of her neck/chin still in the shot with her eyes cropped out. Maybe it wouldn't look good? I dunno...still trying to envision it. lol Great job, I gave this an 8.

Morning aromas
by aKiwi

Comment:
I like this shot. Great lighting here. I also like the steam. Wish the handle was a bit more focused though. I gave this an 8.

Scents of Smell
by EddyG

Comment:
Cool idea for a shot. Love the white flower against the real black background. The oil/water droplet dripping from the flower into the bottom tells me that it's obviously a floral scented perfume. Good work. I gave this an 8.

burnt
by GinaRothfels

Comment:
Clean and simple. Good, solid background. Nice colors on the box and matches. Like the angle of the box and the placement of the burnt matches. Good work. Gave this an 8.

A Pure Scent
by librodo

Comment:
This is very pretty. Love the crop. The flower is beautiful and I love way the petals are slowly opening with the center still tightly closed. I gave this an 8. Probably would have given it a 9 but there seems to be quite a bit of yellow in the shadows of the petals. Nice job.

Just For Men!
by agwright

Comment:
I think this is such a cool shot. I love the bottle in the background. Obviously a ladies perfect bottle. The look of the bottle is perfect for this. I love how you've focused the attention on the 'man' leaving 'her' blurred in the background. It's almost like 'she' is courting him or something. I dunno, maybe I'm reading more into than you had intended, but I love this! The only thing I see a little off with this is the aftershave bottle. It looks tilted when you compare it to the verticle border on the right. Very minor, though. I gave this a 9!