Petal
by welcher

Comment:
Beautifully done!

120 Seconds of Fame
by stephan

Comment:
The bg is very interesting and the banana is a good idea. I like it except for the over-exposed spot on the banana.

Lemon Egg
by Bullwinkle

Comment:
odd picture but technically fine and meets the challenge well. High score.

On The Right Track
by spiderman

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club
The subject is a good one, and popular with many. It's sort of timeless, with little change over the years. So at the same time it is current and nostalgic.
The depth of field seems to work just fine, although I'd like to see the whole a little sharper.
All the wood within the tracks is wonderfully textural and adds much dimension to the image.
I like the crop but, personally, not the angle. I understand it is a matter of personal taste though, and others really like it.
Overall a decent image that could be presented in several different ways.
Regards,

Grayce

Guess which one
by pitsaman

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club!
This image has quite a bit of potential. The birds are an interesting subject and the setting is very good.
The coloring is very drab. It may actually be better as a black and white picture, but the contrast needs to be pumped up a bit and the whole thing needs to be sharper. You could try the unsharp mask in PS or something similar in your software.
About it meeting the challenge, well I don't see a person in the picture, which is what the description asked for. That is very important on this site...to meet the challenge.
I hope this helps. Enjoy yourself!
Regards,

Grayce

Onward Sail
by jerrft

Comment:
I like the composition, and the colors but the focus is a little off.

DixieLand
by RLS

Comment:
Good idea.Wonderfully graphic and very clever name too.

Rows
by greenem2

Comment:
Good. Well exposed, except for the blown out window...can't help that, I guess. I love the subject...shelves of books, and wood floors...love it.

Mariachi Rythm
by JEM

Comment:
Very well meets the challenge. Good rhythm and pattern.

Making Waves
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
Nice take on the challenge. Good color, texture and pattern. A bit over-exposed in spots.