Unconvinced
by tvsometime

Comment:
Despite the title, that guy in the front is really not doing it for me. I think the image would have been stronger without it. The display itself is very nice, and I like that you can see the people in the store. The out of focus guy especially exiting the frame is an eye sore for me. Maybe entering the frame he would have had more impact.

Marcus Book Stores - 50th Anniversary
by GeneralE

Comment:
A well taken photograph that just lacks the little 'extra' element to make this picture pop like the some of this challenges frontrunners. 6

Both worlds
by Alex_Petrini

Comment:
Loving the perspective. One of the most unique of the entire challenge. I just now noticed the footprints in the snow which are very interesting to me. Love how there are two of one world, but only of the other, if that makes sense. I probably would have gone for a slightly closer crop though. Right now it feels a little to disconnected for me. 8

Apple Store Rear Cleavage
by ray_mefarso

Comment:
A well taken image that meets the challenge and is even funny, but unfortunately the subject matter is very unappealing to me. I'll just quickly vote and move on, so that I don't have to analyze this too long 6

Waiting for Christmas
by navilor

Comment:
Wow, this looks like a child's dream. I really love the color tones of this picture.
I am a little baffled, because I really dislike the metal fence in the picture, but can't really find a suitable suggestion of how you could have gotten rid of it or less noticeable, without also making the composition less interesting.
Ah well, its not a big deal anyways 7

Adam's shop
by ionelpop

Comment:
How very bizarre. I can't quite understand this picture. How are there reflections in the frame when clearly it must be empty. How wonderful to contemplate.
I find the second person on the left to be completely useless in the photo though. I am entirely not interested in him. And to put insult to injury his hand is overexposed.

Oh wow, just as I was about to vote and continue, I realized that the reflections are actually on the window that YOU are shooting through, not the frame that he was going through. Tricked me ;-)

Elf Fantasy
by dtremain

Comment:
Very interesting photo with so many things to look at. I would have zoomed in slightly more, so the viewers could read the sign without straining their eyes. I am trying, but its a little too small for me. This way, it just bugs me that I juuuuuust quite can't read it :-P 7

The Christmas Dress
by Scoman

Comment:
Very classy, I quite like this. The composition is most excellent, and I love the out of focus foreground elements (something that is rare for me). Very well done, I don't know how you could have photographed this one better. 8

White Christmas
by haleylbee

Comment:
Is it snowing? I really like that :-)
Anyways, strong composition and it fits the challenge really really well. Something bugs me about the lighting on hte girl though. I feel like it should be a lot warmer. The color tones are too cold for me.
It must have been really difficult to expose that tree like you did. Excellent job 7

Oooh ... how much?
by AllenP

Comment:
Very stylish and well photographed. The store sellers sure do know their lighting, that is for sure. All of the matching tones really bring out this image, and the composition is pretty fine as well. My second favorite image so far (granted I am not even half way done, sorry :-P)