Star Light Express
by donpram

Comment by inspzil:
Greetings from the Critique Club
By Inspzil

Composition - Interesting abstract type shot. Definitely has some appeal as a more modern art type piece with a nice focal point and the blackness broken up with little dots of light. There are 2 problems with this picture IMO. I think with this kind of photo, are you at any disadvantage to get it into portrait format, which would be more conducive to magazine covers in general? And secondly, this picture looks like an illustration as much or more than it looks like a photograph. There are no reference points to indicate what is up or down, left or right, so why not put it portrait? you could flip or rotate all you like legally to achieve this quite simply.

Technically - This is very sharp and well taken. I like that some of the light circles are overexposed, but not all of them. This was good technique used with this photo and favorable angles to accomplish the partial overexposures.

Overall - I don't know this magazine. I'm not sure what the cover would even look like. This is a cool picture. You almost have to sell people into believing its a photograph. Flipping it portrait would've been a logical thing to do, since the greater majority of magazines that I know of are in portrait format. Very interesting image that has a lot of appeal, but maybe not the greatest for this challenge. Good luck with future challenges. - Bob

Star Light Express
by donpram

Comment by K-Rob:
VERY cool! What is that? A ceiling? Looks wonderful.

Star Light Express
by donpram

Comment by luckycharmsrock:
It's a bit busy for a magazine cover

Star Light Express
by donpram

Comment by nevileon:
Neat picture!

Star Light Express
by donpram

Comment by ChrisW123:
Never heard of this magazine. But this is a great picture. Good job I love it. Please describe how you did it!

Star Light Express
by donpram

Comment by qachyk:
I cannot find any indication on if your magazine really exists.

It's hard to judge from the title if this would be an apt magazine cover; the title appears to describe the image.

The image, while visually interesting, is without context for me given the challenge.

Star Light Express
by donpram

Comment by Gracious:
I'm not sure what I'm looking at but this is intriguing. I hope you'll discuss it.

Star Light Express
by donpram

Comment by bgmorris:
Intriguing photo, but I don't see how it fits the contest theme.

Star Light Express
by donpram

Comment by RiderGal:
Personally I do not consider magazines to be in a horizontal shape... thats just me though. I have no clue what the theme of Star Light Express Magazine is... I can't seem to find it on Yahoo. I'm not doubting that it's a real magazine, it's just I have no way to judge whether your photo would be good for the cover or not. Sorry.

Star Light Express
by donpram

Comment by thirteen_times:
Interesting piece. 8.