Crayon, a lot of CCers will not comment on the image unless the photographer has left some kind of information on the photo. We have gotten enough complaints, that we have been considering making it a requirement if you check the box asking for a detailed crit from the CC.
Sorry I'm a couple days late on this, but thought I'd add my inside experiences to the discussion. So, the more information you supply, the better your chances of getting a more detailed crit.
For example, you were trying for a darker photo, and didn't state that. Well, the commentor goes into detail for a half hour about how you could have made the photo brighter. A waste of time for you and the commentor. However, if they know that you were TRYING for that particular look, then they could focus on something else.
Anyway, hope this helps. Again, sorry for the delayed response. |