The 1000th Challenge Comment Challenge

Pentax D-FA* 70-200mm f/2.8 ED DC AW

03/18/2009 08:42:05 PM · #3

Originally posted by K10DGuy:

I actually commented on 102, as 2 of my comments were on DQd shots.

Cool!

I commented on 1127/1113 :P

K3Master

Pentax K-3

03/18/2009 08:36:18 PM · #4

I actually commented on 102, as 2 of my comments were on DQd shots.

Cool!

pedrobop

Canon PowerShot SX100 IS

Canon EF-S 18-135mm f/3.5-5.6 IS

03/18/2009 08:35:17 PM · #5

I commented 103 during voting too. :D

gaurawa

Canon EOS-5D Mark II

Tamron SP AF 17-50mm f/2.8 Di II LD Aspherical (IF) for Canon

03/18/2009 08:31:18 PM · #6

oh well I did cross 100 :) made 101 during voting

bcenu

Canon EOS-40D

03/18/2009 05:50:16 PM · #7

Originally posted by HawkeyeLonewolf:

Congrats to all who performed this amazing feat!

Thanks Kevin.
Don't want to be doing that again in a hurry!
It was a good experience though, and at least made me think a bit more about my critique efforts
on most of the 1000+ photographs on which I had the pleasure of commenting.

03/18/2009 03:01:56 PM · #8

Originally posted by Melethia:

Originally posted by Ja-9:

I did ck that out...I am a paid member until next Sept...so it's not that...when I am on "My Home" and I click on the "Results for Hidden Gems - 1000th Challenge" all the thumb nails come up...but on each one for my vote and comments I have "N/A's"...if I go to "My Profile" and at the left is comments made area...I can click on that and find my comments but THEY ARE NOT CONNECTED.....I am just trying to understand...sometimes I can be very slow in understanding something...Normally when I click on the Results of a challenge my comments and votes appear...I didn't understand why they don't on this one...ya know...the one I slaved over.

Everyone's is displaying this way for this challenge - apparently we broke the site on this one! Fear not, your comments are all still there!

OHHHHHH...that makes sense...now I understand...I am not alone I take it....

03/18/2009 02:46:16 PM · #9

Originally posted by Ja-9:

I did ck that out...I am a paid member until next Sept...so it's not that...when I am on "My Home" and I click on the "Results for Hidden Gems - 1000th Challenge" all the thumb nails come up...but on each one for my vote and comments I have "N/A's"...if I go to "My Profile" and at the left is comments made area...I can click on that and find my comments but THEY ARE NOT CONNECTED.....I am just trying to understand...sometimes I can be very slow in understanding something...Normally when I click on the Results of a challenge my comments and votes appear...I didn't understand why they don't on this one...ya know...the one I slaved over.

Everyone's is displaying this way for this challenge - apparently we broke the site on this one! Fear not, your comments are all still there!

klkitchens

Pentax K-1

Pentax FA 50mm f/1.4 AF

03/18/2009 02:39:27 PM · #10

Congrats to all who performed this amazing feat!

03/18/2009 01:08:23 PM · #11

Originally posted by jeger:

Originally posted by Ja-9:

Originally posted by jeger:

Originally posted by Ja-9:
I finished all my comments and voting and NONE Of them show up when I pull up the Challenge...where are they...all that work...there is something amiss here I would say... and I know someone out there can clear this up for me....

All your comments are there, they just aren't showing up in the thumbnail view. Your effort was not in vain.

yes, I cked on my profile page (comments made) and they are there, but I don't understand that when I open the challenge up to see how my votes rated/comments they are not there...nothing .... zippo

See this tread about votes/comments.

03/18/2009 12:59:30 PM · #12

Originally posted by BAMartin:

BAMartin 66

Wow, what happened to the rest of my comments? I know I made 100 during the voting. This is mysterious and a little sad.

Fixed - that was an error on my part, not the site's. :-)

brumer0

Canon EOS-5D Mark II

03/18/2009 12:59:22 PM · #13

Originally posted by Melethia:

What started out as just a "let's see if we can get 20 people to do this" turned out far, far better than expected. Pat yourselves on the back, folks - you did a great job!

The Century Club

1m1A 100
aKiwi 100
Alain 115
alans_world 214
arati_halbe 100
ArpeggioAngel 172
Art Roflmao 137
BAMartin 100
Bear_Music 150
boyd2000 222
bspurgeon 100
bvy 138
cfarrell 113
CJinCA 100
CNovack 202
citymars 100
cosprenks 137
cynthiann 227
dahkota 109
Damzel 203
digifotobuddy 101
dknourek 153
dougi555 114
dswann 124
elizadeb 104
freakin_hilarious 61
fridjo 104
gaurawa 95
gg3rd 111
GIS_boy 108
halopes 100
hesitant 113
HighNooner 137
jdixonsd 100
JeffryZ 255
JerseyGenie 103
jfwolpert 227
Jutilda 136
K10DGuy 100
k9logic 103
keegbow 111
kelli 100
Ken 201
kevip6 100
kleski 101
L2 100
Ladystarstruck 101
langdon 110
Lonni 102
LVicari 100
maynerd12 100
mchalmers 106
melethia 265
mpeters 139
neophyte 202
njsabs2323 110
pamelasue 151
PennyStreet 221
pekesty 100
rodfulk 251
SaraR 105
scooter97 166
scottieham 223
SDW 116
SJCarter 203
slipintoshadows 100
snaffles 66
Starbanana 145
TallPaul 100
thatsanicepicture 113
tpbremer 100
ursula 130
vawendy 100
WickedB 109
WickedSound 102

...thats impressive

jeger

Canon EOS-5D

03/18/2009 12:57:48 PM · #14

Originally posted by Ja-9:

Originally posted by jeger:

Originally posted by Ja-9:
I finished all my comments and voting and NONE Of them show up when I pull up the Challenge...where are they...all that work...there is something amiss here I would say... and I know someone out there can clear this up for me....

All your comments are there, they just aren't showing up in the thumbnail view. Your effort was not in vain.

yes, I cked on my profile page (comments made) and they are there, but I don't understand that when I open the challenge up to see how my votes rated/comments they are not there...nothing .... zippo

See this tread about votes/comments.

03/18/2009 12:54:47 PM · #15

Originally posted by jeger:

Originally posted by Ja-9:
I finished all my comments and voting and NONE Of them show up when I pull up the Challenge...where are they...all that work...there is something amiss here I would say... and I know someone out there can clear this up for me....

All your comments are there, they just aren't showing up in the thumbnail view. Your effort was not in vain.

yes, I cked on my profile page (comments made) and they are there, but I don't understand that when I open the challenge up to see how my votes rated/comments they are not there...nothing .... zippo

jeger

Canon EOS-5D

Canon EF 28-135mm F/3.5-5.6 IS USM

03/18/2009 09:53:37 AM · #16

Originally posted by Ja-9:

I finished all my comments and voting and NONE Of them show up when I pull up the Challenge...where are they...all that work...there is something amiss here I would say... and I know someone out there can clear this up for me....

All your comments are there, they just aren't showing up in the thumbnail view. Your effort was not in vain.

Kelli

Canon EOS-D60

03/18/2009 09:47:57 AM · #17

Originally posted by Ja-9:

See this thread... link. Your comments are still there. At least I know I still have one from you.

03/18/2009 09:17:43 AM · #18

Jammur

Nikon D300

03/18/2009 08:59:22 AM · #19

Originally posted by BAMartin:

BAMartin 66

Wow, what happened to the rest of my comments? I know I made 100 during the voting. This is mysterious and a little sad.

Perhaps you made the same mistake I did when this weeks Member challenge went into voting.
I clicked on the bottom challenge and voted and commented on a dozen images, then started to wonder why they were all about the same topic...."Hope" :)

BAMartin

Apple iPhone 5

03/18/2009 08:41:26 AM · #20

BAMartin 66

Wow, what happened to the rest of my comments? I know I made 100 during the voting. This is mysterious and a little sad.

03/18/2009 04:03:09 AM · #21

What started out as just a "let's see if we can get 20 people to do this" turned out far, far better than expected. Pat yourselves on the back, folks - you did a great job!

The Century Club

1m1A 100

aKiwi 100

Alain 115

alans_world 214

arati_halbe 100

ArpeggioAngel 172

Art Roflmao 137

BAMartin 100

Bear_Music 150

boyd2000 222

bspurgeon 100

bvy 138

cfarrell 113

CJinCA 100

CNovack 202

citymars 100

cosprenks 137

cynthiann 227

dahkota 109

Damzel 203

digifotobuddy 101

dknourek 153

dougi555 114

dswann 124

elizadeb 104

freakin_hilarious 61

fridjo 104

gaurawa 95

gg3rd 111

GIS_boy 108

halopes 100

hesitant 113

HighNooner 137

jdixonsd 100

JeffryZ 255

JerseyGenie 103

jfwolpert 227

Jutilda 136

K10DGuy 100

k9logic 103

keegbow 111

kelli 100

Ken 201

kevip6 100

kleski 101

L2 100

Ladystarstruck 101

langdon 110

Lonni 102

LVicari 100

maynerd12 100

mchalmers 106

melethia 265

mpeters 139

neophyte 202

njsabs2323 110

pamelasue 151

PennyStreet 221

pekesty 100

rodfulk 251

SaraR 105

scooter97 166

scottieham 223

SDW 116

SJCarter 203

slipintoshadows 100

snaffles 66

Starbanana 145

TallPaul 100

thatsanicepicture 113

tpbremer 100

ursula 130

vawendy 100

WickedB 109

WickedSound 102

Message edited by author 2009-03-18 12:59:07.

03/18/2009 03:56:57 AM · #22

The Energizer Bunny Bunch These daring folks made 300 comments or more - in most cases that would be an entire challenge, and then some!

bmartuch 443

boyd2000 301

eschelar 305

eyewave 325

jammur 1000!!

JDubsgirl 400

jomari 580

Karmat 301

loseme 800

love 441

LydiaToo 705

Nuzzer 666

smudgeSMJ 670

WriteHeart 411

Yo_Spiff 300

Message edited by author 2009-03-18 04:06:52.