DPChallenge: A Digital Photography Contest You are not logged in. (log in or register
 

DPChallenge Forums >> Challenge Announcements >> 'Marshmallow Peeps' Results Recalculated
Pages:  
Showing posts 1 - 25 of 131, (reverse)
AuthorThread
04/03/2008 08:48:35 AM · #1
The results of the 'Marshmallow Peeps' challenge have been recalculated due to the disqualification of the former 6th place image. Congrats to our new top 10!
04/03/2008 09:23:36 AM · #2
WOO HOO! That's bumps me to #10!
04/03/2008 09:27:26 AM · #3
WOO HOO! That's bumps me to #29!
04/03/2008 09:29:21 AM · #4
WOOO HOOO! That bumps...oh wait I didn't enter.
04/03/2008 09:31:42 AM · #5
WOOO HOO! That bumps... oh, it wasn't Aimee. :-/
04/03/2008 09:36:12 AM · #6
Disqualified due to the photographer using a fake Peep.
04/03/2008 09:41:56 AM · #7
updated

//www.shutupmilo.com/scores.htm
04/03/2008 09:46:39 AM · #8
Originally posted by hopper:

updated

//www.shutupmilo.com/scores.htm


Whoa....... do most people know you're doing this.......cool =16th, now I'm wrapped and motivated even more.....!

thnx
555

Message edited by author 2008-04-03 09:47:03.
04/03/2008 09:48:22 AM · #9
Sorry for the DQ....but happy to now be in 9th place!
04/03/2008 10:33:37 AM · #10
Originally posted by dougi555:

Whoa....... do most people know you're doing this.......


probably not
04/03/2008 09:05:03 PM · #11
Originally posted by scalvert:

WOOO HOO! That bumps... oh, it wasn't Aimee. :-/

Hey now
: )
04/03/2008 10:14:02 PM · #12
Only on this site can you get ramed and not do a damn thing about it!!! 653917.gif


04/03/2008 10:18:12 PM · #13
Now if they could DQ the first five I'll be ok
04/04/2008 02:49:59 AM · #14
So what was the exact violation? Was the balloon suspended by something, then removed in post-processing?
04/04/2008 03:04:48 AM · #15
Originally posted by AperturePriority:

So what was the exact violation? Was the balloon suspended by something, then removed in post-processing?

He posted the original in his entry comments
04/04/2008 03:06:13 AM · #16
To save folks some time...
665574.jpg 661425.jpg
04/04/2008 04:41:33 AM · #17
This is an area of DPchallenge that kills me. The rule on this topic is so vague and leaves the interpretation up to the site council. If you look at Scalverts entry as an example, He cloned out fishing line, which is sort of the same thing here isnt it?

Where is the cheeseman when you need him?
04/04/2008 04:56:11 AM · #18
Originally posted by ShutterHack:

Where is the cheeseman when you need him?

He was cloned out. :(
04/04/2008 07:02:42 AM · #19
I think the areas that were cloned out were not prominent enough to affect my point of view for this image. It's advanced editing...
04/04/2008 07:07:12 AM · #20
Originally posted by ShutterHack:

This is an area of DPchallenge that kills me. The rule on this topic is so vague and leaves the interpretation up to the site council. If you look at Scalverts entry as an example, He cloned out fishing line, which is sort of the same thing here isnt it?

Where is the cheeseman when you need him?


Can you suggest a more objective wording? We've tried for years but have yet to come up with one.

~Terry
04/04/2008 07:20:56 AM · #21
Originally posted by Dirt_Diver:

I think the areas that were cloned out were not prominent enough to affect my point of view for this image. It's advanced editing...


I agree, Like power lines or something.
04/04/2008 07:28:47 AM · #22
Can you suggest a more objective wording? We've tried for years but have yet to come up with one.

~Terry


Yes, why not state that you can clone out any portion of a submission which assisted in the setup, display, or prop as long as the original background is not changed in a way to misrepresent the original.

Gators editing is no different that scavert's or anyone else that has cloned out fishing line etc.
04/04/2008 07:47:35 AM · #23
As someone that has been around here for a long time, this latest disqualification is so inconsistent with what we have seen allowed in the past. I rarely jump up & down on issues, but this was wrong in my opinion. I could easily show examples of setup props, strings, even background supports that were cloned out or removed that were no different than this shot.

What a shame.
04/04/2008 08:00:27 AM · #24
standing by for Ken's artwork...
04/04/2008 08:08:33 AM · #25
Originally posted by Brad:

........snip....... this was wrong in my opinion. I could easily show examples of setup props, strings, even background supports that were cloned out or removed that were no different than this shot.

What a shame.

Oh my! I agree. :-O
Pages:  
Current Server Time: 02/18/2019 01:49:43 AM

Please log in or register to post to the forums.


Home - Challenges - Community - League - Photos - Cameras - Lenses - Learn - Prints! - Help - Terms of Use - Privacy - Top ^
DPChallenge, and website content and design, Copyright © 2001-2019 Challenging Technologies, LLC.
All digital photo copyrights belong to the photographers and may not be used without permission.
Proudly hosted by Sargasso Networks. Current Server Time: 02/18/2019 01:49:43 AM EST.