Author | Thread |
|
04/03/2007 09:26:33 PM · #676 |
I am actually voting on other challenges
Originally posted by Nuzzer: Originally posted by Monique64: Quick question: I am voting on some of the current submissions and am having trouble on how to score. When scoring how much weight does photo vs idea and relevance to theme have.
What is an average score when you like something but it doesn't have that extra something. What if a photo is really good, but doesn't fit the challenge as well as some. What if it doesn't fit the challenge at all. One of my instructors said that a lot of thought should be given to the composition as well as the title that you give a photo. Obviously these are important, but are they just as important as the quality of the photo? |
It's a Free Study so everything should fit the challenge. |
|
|
|
04/03/2007 09:28:16 PM · #677 |
Originally posted by Rebecca: Originally posted by Monique64: Quick question: I am voting on some of the current submissions and am having trouble on how to score. When scoring how much weight does photo vs idea and relevance to theme have.
What is an average score when you like something but it doesn't have that extra something. What if a photo is really good, but doesn't fit the challenge as well as some. What if it doesn't fit the challenge at all. One of my instructors said that a lot of thought should be given to the composition as well as the title that you give a photo. Obviously these are important, but are they just as important as the quality of the photo? |
No one can answer that for you. Trying will only start flame wars. Once you've been here awhile, you figure out a system that works for you and that's that. |
Thanks, just want to give photos what they deserve. |
|
|
04/03/2007 09:31:32 PM · #678 |
Originally posted by Monique64: Originally posted by Rebecca: Originally posted by Monique64: Quick question: I am voting on some of the current submissions and am having trouble on how to score. When scoring how much weight does photo vs idea and relevance to theme have.
What is an average score when you like something but it doesn't have that extra something. What if a photo is really good, but doesn't fit the challenge as well as some. What if it doesn't fit the challenge at all. One of my instructors said that a lot of thought should be given to the composition as well as the title that you give a photo. Obviously these are important, but are they just as important as the quality of the photo? |
No one can answer that for you. Trying will only start flame wars. Once you've been here awhile, you figure out a system that works for you and that's that. |
Thanks, just want to give photos what they deserve. |
Please remember though that in a "Free Study" there is no specific topic, so all entries by definition "fit" the challenge. If, on the other hand, you're talking about how well composition, title, and technical quality fit together, then, you need to apply your own best judgment.
Message edited by author 2007-04-03 21:32:10. |
|
|
04/03/2007 09:35:05 PM · #679 |
Originally posted by ursula: Originally posted by Monique64: Originally posted by Rebecca: Originally posted by Monique64: Quick question: I am voting on some of the current submissions and am having trouble on how to score. When scoring how much weight does photo vs idea and relevance to theme have.
What is an average score when you like something but it doesn't have that extra something. What if a photo is really good, but doesn't fit the challenge as well as some. What if it doesn't fit the challenge at all. One of my instructors said that a lot of thought should be given to the composition as well as the title that you give a photo. Obviously these are important, but are they just as important as the quality of the photo? |
No one can answer that for you. Trying will only start flame wars. Once you've been here awhile, you figure out a system that works for you and that's that. |
Thanks, just want to give photos what they deserve. |
Please remember though that in a "Free Study" there is no specific topic, so all entries by definition "fit" the challenge. If, on the other hand, you're talking about how well composition, title, and technical quality fit together, then, you need to apply your own best judgment. |
I realise that, I also received a DNMC1 in the free study, I am currently voting in other challenges.
Message edited by author 2007-04-03 21:38:24. |
|
|
04/03/2007 09:43:45 PM · #680 |
Originally posted by Monique64: Originally posted by ursula: Originally posted by Monique64: Originally posted by Rebecca: Originally posted by Monique64: Quick question: I am voting on some of the current submissions and am having trouble on how to score. When scoring how much weight does photo vs idea and relevance to theme have.
What is an average score when you like something but it doesn't have that extra something. What if a photo is really good, but doesn't fit the challenge as well as some. What if it doesn't fit the challenge at all. One of my instructors said that a lot of thought should be given to the composition as well as the title that you give a photo. Obviously these are important, but are they just as important as the quality of the photo? |
No one can answer that for you. Trying will only start flame wars. Once you've been here awhile, you figure out a system that works for you and that's that. |
Thanks, just want to give photos what they deserve. |
Please remember though that in a "Free Study" there is no specific topic, so all entries by definition "fit" the challenge. If, on the other hand, you're talking about how well composition, title, and technical quality fit together, then, you need to apply your own best judgment. |
I realise that, I also received a DNMC1 in the free study, I am currently voting in other challenges. |
Ah, allright, I thought you meant this challenge. The DNMC - 1 was a prank (April Fool's Day), and it's being changed by the "prankster". |
|
|
04/03/2007 09:46:23 PM · #681 |
Votes: 116
Views: 197
Avg Vote: 6.4655
Comments: 13
i thought a 6.0 would be a stretch! up from the 6.2 i had after april fools, i hope it keeps going, soooo excited. :) |
|
|
04/03/2007 09:55:58 PM · #682 |
Votes: 114
Views: 151
Avg Vote: 6.5088
Comments: 9
|
|
|
04/03/2007 10:08:03 PM · #683 |
Just wanted to add if you folks dont believe the pic is real just ask for it to be verified, and score it as if you believed it to be real. |
|
|
04/03/2007 10:58:38 PM · #684 |
Votes: 125
Views: 201
Avg Vote: 6.6000
Comments: 11
Favorites: 0
Looks like April Fool's still isn't over. The 1 I just received lowered me by 0.05. |
|
|
04/03/2007 11:06:59 PM · #685 |
Originally posted by mad_brewer: ..Avg Vote: 6.6000
...
|
That's a great score in a Free Study :) |
|
|
04/03/2007 11:13:32 PM · #686 |
Originally posted by mad_brewer: Votes: 125
Views: 201
Avg Vote: 6.6000
Comments: 11
Favorites: 0
Looks like April Fool's still isn't over. The 1 I just received lowered me by 0.05. |
I'll trade ya, my score is 6.2xxx
|
|
|
04/03/2007 11:24:08 PM · #687 |
I just received a 1 too. I dropped .07
|
|
|
04/03/2007 11:30:37 PM · #688 |
Hey. . .I must have too. My score dropped a bunch after one vote too. Darn! See? this IS a vindictive challenge, isn't it.
|
|
|
04/03/2007 11:32:08 PM · #689 |
Originally posted by mobster: Originally posted by mad_brewer: Votes: 125
Views: 201
Avg Vote: 6.6000
Comments: 11
Favorites: 0
Looks like April Fool's still isn't over. The 1 I just received lowered me by 0.05. |
I'll trade ya, my score is 6.2xxx |
I think this is only my 2nd free study over a 6 so I'll take it. Believe me, I appreciate what I have! |
|
|
04/03/2007 11:35:37 PM · #690 |
100 vote check-in. :) Looking a whole lot better than that 3.8xxx on day 1!
Votes: 100
Views: 133
Avg Vote: 5.7500
Comments: 7 |
|
|
04/04/2007 01:07:32 AM · #691 |
Just finished voting, and I have to say, this time the Free Study just looks different. A lot of moody photos and a lot of experimental processing. I actually loved voting this one. I've been hanging around in Holga forums lately, and bringing that viewing experience here was refreshing. The photos I loved most tended to be well-captured moments. They weren't technically perfect, but the timing was spot on. Or they were a little more experimental, a bit outside the stock-influenced fare we tend to see. For some the imperfections that DPC typically would pick on were precisely the things that I loved about them. I was compelled to comment more than I have done lately (overloaded with school). Some of it was bad, some of it blew me away, and those extremes both seemed to happen more with this one. It looks like most people stepped outside of their comfort zone and DPC just doesn't know quite what to do with that.
Anyway, thought I might comment on my voting experience, see if it resonates with anyone else.
I'm just below a 5.6 right now, and after seeing what's out there that feels about right.
Message edited by author 2007-04-04 01:09:19.
|
|
|
04/04/2007 02:06:46 AM · #692 |
What the deuce? I still have my "DNMC 1" comment and it has this for the time stamp:
04/03/2007 06:48:31 PM
|
|
|
04/04/2007 02:11:51 AM · #693 |
Originally posted by glad2badad: 100 vote check-in. :) Looking a whole lot better than that 3.8xxx on day 1!
Votes: 100
Views: 133
Avg Vote: 5.7500
Comments: 7 |
I got a 3.8 on day one and it wasn't a joke apparently. I've climbed up a couple tenths of a point though! Happy to see that you've gone far past that range! |
|
|
04/04/2007 03:09:56 AM · #694 |
Votes: 112
Views: 186
Avg Vote: 6.6786
Comments: 7
Favorites: 1
No ribbon, but might just keep me close enough to Larus in the Marathon |
|
|
04/04/2007 04:35:57 AM · #695 |
Hopefully enough to get into top fifteen.
Votes: 116
Views: 195
Avg Vote: 7.1466
Comments: 18
Favorites: 3 |
|
|
04/04/2007 07:30:48 AM · #696 |
Originally posted by Citadel: What the deuce? I still have my "DNMC 1" comment and it has this for the time stamp:
04/03/2007 06:48:31 PM |
My guess is copycat. My original was "dnmc 1", without the caps, and the prankster probably copied and pasted. |
|
|
04/04/2007 08:26:03 AM · #697 |
Okay my dnmc 1 has been removed and replaced with supposedly a 6 vote, strange thing is that my score hasnt changed and is still 5.2xxx. With about 100 votes a jump from 1 to 6 should have changed my score by how much, it is too early in the morning for me to work this out so I am going to rely on you mathamaticians to help me out here.
Thanks guys.
|
|
|
04/04/2007 08:35:42 AM · #698 |
Votes: 115
Views: 146
Avg Vote: 5.8000
Comments: 2
|
|
|
04/04/2007 09:40:57 AM · #699 |
Originally posted by loriprophoto: Okay my dnmc 1 has been removed and replaced with supposedly a 6 vote, strange thing is that my score hasnt changed and is still 5.2xxx. With about 100 votes a jump from 1 to 6 should have changed my score by how much, it is too early in the morning for me to work this out so I am going to rely on you mathamaticians to help me out here.
Thanks guys. |
It would have changed it by less than a tenth since 5 is so close to 5.2, so it would hard to notice without tracking all digits. |
|
|
04/04/2007 10:15:32 AM · #700 |
Votes: 109
Views: 145
Avg Vote: 5.0367
Yippe!!!! My score is finally above a 4. Now to see if it'll beat my best score of 5.4. I'm not picky :) |
|
Home -
Challenges -
Community -
League -
Photos -
Cameras -
Lenses -
Learn -
Prints! -
Help -
Terms of Use -
Privacy -
Top ^
DPChallenge, and website content and design, Copyright © 2001-2024 Challenging Technologies, LLC.
All digital photo copyrights belong to the photographers and may not be used without permission.
Current Server Time: 03/28/2024 09:50:24 PM EDT.