Financial District - upside down
by HeiSch

Comment:
I love the detail in the cityscape and the reflection, I am really not sure though if I like that thick band going through the middle, if that had been half the depth it would have been an awesome image, as it is it's still stunning but sits a little awkward. I would love to see this as a straight shot without the reflection it's the sort of thing I could see sitting on a studio flat wall.

Comment Only

Mixed Up Forest
by kayt300994

Comment:
I suspect this will get caned in the voting for being too small and an unconventional crop, also whilst it looks like a reflection as there is no above / below to the image it could almost be a pure flip of an image.

Comment Only

Are you going to give me hand here, or just take pictures?
by ShutterPug

Comment:
Good idea and nice detail in this shot. The main thing that I think lets it down is that harsh light causing those heavy shadows and the falloff top left is quite distracting.

Comment Only

Blue Heron Preening
by hihosilver

Comment:
Unlike the flamingo shots in this challenge the Herons head is not upside down and whilst I gave the other shots a bit of leaway as they could almost be considered fitting for the challenge I don't think this shot can be considered to do so.

Comment Only

Mirror, Mirror
by halopes

Comment:
Nice capture, interesting composition and I really like the space left for the cyclist, I might have cropped a little more on the right though as I don't think is a bit of dead space, in one respect it adds balance to the cyclist but in another it kind of makes it too symetrical and looks a bit awkward.

Comment Only

misty watercolor memories
by skewsme

Comment:
Unfortunately this one doesn't scream upside down to me, I can see it's a reflection but it's kind of limited in how it portrays the subject, which is further hurt by the fact that the water is not very still so you get an almost OOF effect.

Comment Only

Shadowplay
by jonfrommk

Comment:
Nice shadow which makes a nice change from all of the reflection shots, I think it may be a bit too heavy though and makes the composition a bit awkward, I would also have liked to see some fill light on the backside of the child to add some detail to the legs and underside area.

Comment Only

Seaworld
by Rino63

Comment:
I see the reflections as upside down but I think like most of the other entries it might have worked a bit better flipped to exagerate the effect. Looks like there might be a blue cast over the image which might affect your score a bit.

Comment Only

A Hunter's Moon
by Lonz

Comment:
My main problem with this is the harsh line across the top right, I like the silhoutte and I like the lighting but that triangle is really distracting.

Comment Only

A Blue Note
by gunsmith6

Comment:
OOF, blue colour cast and not particularly inspiring :(

Comment Only