Old Millby
bfurnerComment by freakin_hilarious: **Critique Club**
First off, congrats on your new PB by quite a ways! This really is an excellent submission. It meets the challenge head on (it really looks like it could be a postcard) and it's a beautiful shot. Excellent use of border and text as well. In the image itself you combined several DPC friendly elements, and they paid off. You've got smooth water, great composition, a lovely landscape and a nice B/W conversion.
There are only a couple of things that I see that may have brought your score down a bit. First, the whole thing feels like it is leaning a bit to the right. That may or may not be true, but I would prefer a small rotation. Second, the white water in the foreground is totally blown out. The B/W helps that, but it's still a bit distracting. Finally, it could be sharper. You might want to check out
this thread on Adamus sharpening. I bet it would work wonderfully on this image.
Overall, a great image, score, and placement. My recommended tweaks are pretty minor, but they may have improved your score a little. Great job!
If you have any questions or comments just shoot me a PM.
Nathan