Onions
by katlyn

Comment:
These definately have a strong scent! I think this shot could have been improved by better focus, possibly a sharpen. It would have been better on a solid surface or in a basket maybe.... Lighting seems good.

Memories of my Grandfather
by Ten13

Comment:
I still remember this scent from my Grandfather. I like your subject, but it would be better if the slight line of glare could have been eliminated. I wonder if it would have helped to bounce the light? I like the shadow the bottle casts.

Boy...this stinks!
by tlg42775

Comment:
An adorable kitten - and he does have a look on his face like it stinks. You might have tried cropping a bit tighter on the left to take out that carpet. It seems a tad bit of detail is lost in the kittens face, maybe a slight sharpen would have helped? This isn't a shot that can easily be redone and capture that look though. :-)

Funny Smelling
by WildflowerJoy

Comment:
Interesting concept for the challenge. I can make out lemon, lime, red onion - but if there is any other type of food, I can't determine what it is. You have some distracting glares on the bowl.

Scents from the Kitchen
by utopian mang

Comment:
The glare from the glasses is distracting... you might try bouncing the light next time - it looks like it might be pointing right at the glasses from the side or above? Since you have a glass lying down in the background, it might have helped to shoot this at a bit higher of an angle. There is a bit of grain as well, that might have been from adjusting the color balances too much? Over all nice idea, but I think if you play with the lighting a bit, you might find better results. Since it appears to be breakfast food, how about trying this in some natural light...

Just For Men!
by agwright

Comment:
Composition and lighting are good. This looks almost like an ad in a magazine. Definately applies to a scents and aromas challenge. The frame / border is good - I think it adds to the image. I like the 'woman shaped' bottle in the background - excellent idea. My only pick is that the Calvin Klein bottle appears ever so slightly tilted in the frame. Nice Work :-)

A Scoopfull of Nuts
by ScantyNebula

Comment:
Excellent composition. Lighting is good, this image really appeals to me. Well done!!

Sunset at Siphon's Draw
by Artifacts

Comment:
You made a nice choice - a beautiful shot with striking color. I love the layers from deep blue to deep orange/red. The cactus sillouhetes add interest. Well done :-)

Guess Who?
by Firstrich1

Comment:
Congrats Richard on a well deserved ribbon! Excellent shot :-)

Splash!
by arnit

Comment:
Congrats on the blue ribbon arnit - another great shot, as always :-)