sweet view
by rutger

Comment:
This image is fascinating and amazing on many different levels. 10 and adding to favorites. Basic editing rules, right?. I'm flabbergasted. This looks too perfect. Reserve me a signed copy.

Still on the move
by MAK

Comment:
Beautiful still life. I don't see the motion. I think I know what you were going for but that would be perceived, and not actual motion. This will be a great test of the concept of the relevance of DNMC votes. If this were free study I'd give it an 8 or 9. Since the intent is there and it's not a shoehorn or outright attempt not to meet the challenge, I will still give it a passing score of 5. Sorry.

If it turns out this ribbons and everyone reading my comments afterwards thinks I'm a close minded idiot for not seeing how perfectly well this shot fit the challenge, I'm holding you personally responsible :)

What cat?
by Judi

Comment:
Nice still life but I don't think you've captured the motion part of the challenge very well. 6

Time Kills
by Photologist

Comment:
Good idea, however, the basic premise is to start with an interesting still life. I don't think you've done so.

Still life submerged
by Refinnej

Comment:
There were quite a few variations of fruit and moving water in the challenge. Yours is best.

Scissors make a gutsy move
by hammersam

Comment:
Certainly the most clever entry in the challenge but photo itself is just OK.

Footy prints
by scotthadl

Comment:
Creative interpretation.

The big one's still out there
by cogerox

Comment:
The mechanical contraption seemingly hanging in space and seemingly not a reflection makes the photo more interesting. I like the enigmatic nature. 8

the impression of a lake
by rodgers_le

Comment:
Your title is horrible. Let the picture speak for itself.

Dreams of Pink Petals
by jenesis

Comment:
Great balance between photo and processing. 8