Circle in the tide
by JustineNZ

Comment by shadow:
For this contest everyone who has the word “circle” in their title is getting a max 10 score. This is a copy and paste version that I am including in every photo that I upgrade to 10 due to the title. We as members of DPchallenge need to be reminded of the topic of the challenge – we really need to reread the topic every time we reach a photo. If circle is in the title and it is appropriate I will give a 10. I am sorry if you do not agree with my method of voting – but scores are all I have.

Circle in the tide
by JustineNZ

Comment by HBunch:
Well, it's circular but doesn't appear to be a circle. I guess that works for me. The subject doesn't hold me in a keep me there. it seems to be lacking a point of interest. There appears to be quite a bit of noise in the forground on the path mostly. The sky colors are nice, but wondering what a bit of hue/saturation adjustments would do. Having the 'circle' dead center of the photo doesn't seem to be the most ideal crop for the photo...but maybe it is for the challenge. ~Heather~

Circle in the tide
by JustineNZ

Comment by cools98:
Fit Challenge Criteria: 1/2
Contrast/Colors: 1/2
Photo Quality: 1/2
Compositoin: 1/2
My Subjective Affinity: 0/2

Circle in the tide
by JustineNZ

Comment by jrtodd:
Subject Impact: Could be more to the point of the challenge
Meets Challenge: May Meet Challenge
Technical: Average
Composition: Good
Creativity: Good Idea

Score: 4

Circle in the tide
by JustineNZ

Comment by TheStick:
Nice find! I think I would have crop'd a bit more off the bottom since the railing is a little distracting. 9

Circle in the tide
by JustineNZ

Comment by Evaan:
Very creative way to meet the challenge. I like it. 6

Circle in the tide
by JustineNZ

Comment by res0m50r:
Fit to challenge criteria: 2/2
Contrast/Colors: 1/2
Photo Quality: 1/2
Composition: 1/2
My subjective affinity: 1/2

Circle in the tide
by JustineNZ

Comment by Matthew:
interesting, but not terribly fitting for challenge. colours muted (up the saturation!), foreground a little too dark. post in foreground distracts.

Circle in the tide
by JustineNZ

Comment by wondersusan:
cool capture

Circle in the tide
by JustineNZ

Comment by asitv:
distracting foreground