Luftballons
by essay

Comment:
Well, it's not an illegal effect... but I don't think it improves your image much. I know this place from an image in a photo club, really cool place!

Dont Look Down
by gaz

Comment:
Nice colors, but the depth of field is a bit too shallow and the subject uninteresting.

Water drops
by slc25336

Comment:
It's nice, but it's still just water droplets... not sure such a shallow DoF works here, I think a bit deeper (maybe the second one could be in half-focus?) would've been better.

Nightfall on the Snow-Covered Tracks
by bcrants

Comment:
A bit centered and uninteresting to me. Good tones, though a bit more local contrast would've improved it IMO.

Night At The (Glass) Museum
by smardaz

Comment:
Nice location, but a bit busy in some places and very empty in others. Very nice color, and you placed the main elements well. Sweet stars on the lights.

ETA: Why is there a black band on the right? I don't remember that being there before...

Message edited by author 2010-02-17 01:08:49.

Waiting for the light at the end of the tunnel...
by sarampo

Comment:
Wow, this is cool. Very much deserving of a ribbon. You could send a ticket to the SC and ask them to change the spelling, I'm sure they wouldn't mind.

Message edited by author 2010-02-16 20:08:28.

Escher's Study
by Neil

Comment:

Originally posted by benee: Alright Neil - good work during your visit to campus! Perfect chance to use the new fisheye. I work just a yards from this building. It used to be the main library on campus, until the built Firestone in the 1940s.

Aww, man! You should've met up with us when we were there!

OEDILF-EditingPrefs-SSv2.jpg
by GeneralE

Comment:
Too complicated for me. deviantART had these four options - "No comments" "Critiques Discouraged" "Critiques Welcome" "Critiques Encouraged" (or something like that) - until critiques were made into a whole separate feature (separate from comments) that you can only request if you pay for a subscription. Those four were good enough in my opinion... in this case, you can't say "rewrite the image" so that eliminates a couple of your choices... and there's not much back-and-forth, so that eliminates the "I won't be able to respond" because DPCers don't usually respond to critiques/comments anyway.

Message edited by author 2010-02-16 15:29:13.

Excuse me...is this seat taken?
by k9logic

Comment:
I have nothing to say, except... instant fave.

Escher's Study
by Neil

Comment:
Hey, I know this place! Glad to see your shot did so well. Congrats on the ribbon, this shot definitely deserves one :)

Message edited by author 2010-02-15 18:45:20.