Airborneby
MarkComment: Hi-ho from the Cirtique Club...
Just reading your comments, and those of the commenters, I think you're being a little hard on yourself. This is a cool photo. It didn't do all that well in the challenge, but the small number of comments tell me that most voters didn't 'get' it rather than thought there were flaws in the image.
It would have been really neat to have the background more out of focus.. As you noted in your comments it's a little busy maybe, but your sisters expression and the big kick to the head more than make up for that!
The exposure is good, with only the small white sky highlights top right distracting my eye from the energy and motion in the shot. The colours are great as well, the strong greens and skintone are pleasing to the eye, with nothing challenging to grasp for the viewer.
The only thing I find disturbing is that the top of the photo is cut off by the frame for the swing. It's almost as if there are two photos here, the one above and the one below. Cropping off the top of the image, keeping most of the wooden framing makes this more balanced to my eye.
I think this image suffered in the voting because people didn't get 'perspective' from the photo. That asside you obviously saw what you wanted, and captured it perfectly. Well done.
Cheers, Chris H.