Rose #1
by GentleSoul

Comment by sher:
beautiful! love the rich color and perfect lighting!

Rose #1
by GentleSoul

Comment by buzzrock:
Nice

Rose #1
by GentleSoul

Comment by Bosborne:
Would love to see the original. Very nice lighting...

Rose #1
by GentleSoul

Comment by Pug-H:
Superb. The only thing that bothers me is the horizontal light blob on the right because it tends to lead the eye off the picture.(the vertical ones are okay).

Rose #1
by GentleSoul

Comment by Melethia:
Lovely presentation! The petals look like velvet.

Rose #1
by GentleSoul

Comment by Jutilda:
I get sick of roses, but MAN, you made a liar out of me with this one. AWESOME. Such beautiful detail and color. Looks like velvet! Terrific capture.

Dangerous Potluck Club (...who will get food poisoning this week?)
by GentleSoul

Comment by Phil:
Greetings from the Critique Club Elizabeth!

First impression: Good shot. Needs a bit more color to appease the voters but I find it quite nice.

Tough image for me to critique as the technicals are pretty much all there. The lighting leaves the color a bit flat but I don't think that's what hurt your overall score here. The thing that got you is the added "blurb". People really toughened up on images that even had an "a" in between the words (Don't Pour "a" Coke, Did "a" Peacock Crow) so I'm not surprised yours was voted down for adding more info in parenthesis. Other than that I think it's fine.

Overall a good image.

Thanks for the opportunity to critique this photo Elizabeth!

Cheers - Phil

Dangerous Potluck Club (...who will get food poisoning this week?)
by GentleSoul

Comment by train:
LOL! Nice idea well done Nice clear image

Dangerous Potluck Club (...who will get food poisoning this week?)
by GentleSoul

Comment by KiwiShotz:
Gret title , invokes all sorts of creepy visions ... and is let down by the pic a little. I'd love to see something looking a littl more dangerous that his rather amused look. The pic would be good with a cheeky title etc etc

Dangerous Potluck Club (...who will get food poisoning this week?)
by GentleSoul

Comment by sherpet:
Again another entry with to much information as the rule of the challenge was DPC only re the words in the title,,,,,