Seafood in the Old Town
by Bear_Music

Comment:
What I like:
- the setting, wherever this was taken, it looks gorgeous!
- light is very pretty

What I don't like
- I am more visually interested in the scenery around the fish than the fish. I love those green shutters!

Overall: for me this shot is attention grabbing for the background rather than the subject

Global Impact
by Lydia

Comment:
What I like
- this is a neat shot, live all the refections on the glass

What I don't like
- wish framing was a bit different. I think it looks better if some of the left side us cropped so that the glass isn't dead center in the shot

Overall: nicely done. Looks like an advert for PETA or an environmental group.

The Imposter
by glad2badad

Comment:
What I like:
- the set up/ idea of this shot.

What I don't like
- while the imposter pops in this scene, the actual fish does not. Focus on real fish is also blurred.

Overall: position of the live fish makes it take up very little of the frame and therefor a bit hard to see.

Wonder
by markwiley

Comment:
What I like
- reflection of the child
- has je ne sais quoi

What I don't like
- child's foot is cut out of frame
- overhead lighting. If this was candid, no way to help that... But if staged, an assistant with a diffuser screen would have been nice, I think, to cut down on some of the overhead light.

Overall: lovely shot of childhood wonder.

Colour my world
by Judi

Comment:
What I like:
- beautiful colors
- nice focus, DoF nicely done.

What I don't like:
- image is a tad too sharp, halos are visible around the fish

Overall: editing is off a bit

Comments made on phone, score to follow- sorry for any typos.

Mid stream at Fishbone Falls
by daisydavid

Comment:
What I like:
- visually very interesting

What I don't like:
- not sure exactly what I'm looking at

Overall: sure, I have no idea what this is but it has style and feels moody and I keep coming back to it. I like it.

In the tank
by MadMan2k

Comment:
What I like:
- colors are great

What I don't like
- focus on fish is soft. Wish shutter speed had been higher... Or perhaps it was from shooting though glass?

Overall: picture is a bit busy. Nice tank, though.

I told you !!
by josaa

Comment:
I normally say what I like/don't like but with this pic I can't

It just works! Beautifully sharp, great texture (The saturation is a bit more than I usually like, but again, it works.)

My favorite of the bunch.

Claustrophobia
by timfythetoo

Comment:
What I like:
- use of b/w. Excellent use to help show the pattern, texture of fish
- that fish in upper right corner, love that it appears to be looking at the camera

What I don't like
- focus is a bit soft

Overall: I love this shot. Excellent. It is so visually interesting.

Comments made on phone, score to follow- sorry for any typos.

Imbedded
by herfotoman

Comment:
What I like:
- the color of the fish really pops against the blue of the water

What I don't like
- nothing is in focus
- not sure if this is a composite shot or multiple exposures or how it was done but I'm having a hard time figuring out what the carpet is suppose to be conveying in this shot.

Overall: I'm guessing the blur was done on purpose to make it seem like the various components are one- but this picture is too busy for my taste.

Comments made on phone, score to follow- sorry for any typos.