Aqvarium
by Mona

Comment:
What I like:
- pose of the fish

What I don't like
- out of focus
- glare on glass.

Overall: nothing is in focus, taking away from what could have been a pretty shot.

s w o o s h
by Ja-9

Comment:
What I like:
- beautiful color
-the movement

What I don't like:
- only negative is that without context it would be hard, for me, to figure out that this is a fish.

Overall: gorgeous photo- can't wait to see what your camera settings and edits were.

do like one
by mitalapo

Comment:
What I like:
- take on the subject

What I don't like:
- framing

Overall: there isn't anything "wrong" with this photo, technically.
I just don't much care for it. I'd have preferred more of the face to be present.

Frying Pan Aquarium
by P-A-U-L

Comment:
What I like:
- it made me laugh: very clever way to play with your supper.

What I don't like: no complaints it's a great shot!

Catch of the Day
by ThingFish

Comment:
What I like:
- full DoF

What I don't like:
- light is harsh on the fishmonger's face. I can only see what one of his hands is doing and the angle of his head makes it seem like he was interrupted from his work

Overall: love the idea and framing of this shot but wish it showed more of how the man was preparing the fish. As an action shot it lacks intention for me.

minnowing
by tnun

Comment:
What I like;
- idea of this shot. That some minnows have me caught while others flee

What I don't like: colors are a bit bland.
- if not for the title I may not have been able to figure out that was a net rather than a piece of garbage.

Overall: wish framing was such as to better tell that the net is a net.

here's looking at you
by tvsometime

Comment:
What I like:
- it's gruesome, definitely got a reaction out of me. Use of b/w really highlights the death stares of these fish.

What I don't like
- it's unsettling to look at- and thus an uncomfortable emotion

Overall: not all pics are meant to make you feel sunshine and happiness. This one feels very cold. Well done.

Florida Reef
by Jules1x

Comment:
What I like:
- beautiful color, this one really jumped at me from the thumbnail view.

What I don't like
- wish the fish wasn't swimming away from camera.

Overall: with framing of fish, it appears that he's in a hurry to get out of the frame. I wish this was zoomed out just a tad.

~fish-o-potamus~
by KMcC

Comment:
What I like
- the framing

What I don't like
- soft focus
- colors are bland/ could use more pop

Overall: wondering how this would look as a b/w with focus on bringing out textures.

... and sometimes they protect us from the sun
by bjoern

Comment:
What I like:
- I like the idea of this shot: life mirroring art.

What I don't like:
- woman's hand isn't actually blocking the sunlight (at least not to both eyes) so it makes me believe that this shot is posed. As a posed shot, I think the positioning of the model could be better. Her purse looks strange sitting in mid air

Overall: great idea but falls a bit flat for me.