Kodak EasyShare DX6340
by BooZon

Comment:
Excellent idea and would work well as an advert.

reassuringly expensive
by Harryg

Comment:
Good composition. Let down by wrinkled label and blown out highlights at base of glass. Feels refreshing though and thus communicates essence of a cool beer.

Before heading to work, I need my java.
by ladpupmoe

Comment:
Java? What;s java? Not knowing what it is the advert rather passes me by. Funny shot though and well executed.

Outdoor Type
by MAK

Comment:
Nicely shot. An effective advert though computer lacks sharpness - probably a consequence of 150kb submission limits. Well done.

Safe & Sane Refreshment
by SamT

Comment:
A good idea but fails to appeal as an advertising shot. Its the table covering that lets it down. Adverts usually have a strong studio feel if shot indoors.

Never a Day Without Charmin
by wwwavenger

Comment:
I'm looking for an almost instant advert hit - buy this! But what am i supposed to feel attracted towards here? Maybe Charmin is relevant? Don't know what it is. Technically though a fine image with effective framing and use of depth of field.

Outside in
by geewhy

Comment:
Easily best of the challenge. Superlative textures and the composition (using a window) is such an imaginative use of selective saturation. A thing of beauty. Well done. 10

The Wake Maker
by vtruan

Comment:
This is a compelling capture and with interesting and absorbing movement. I want to see more of this creature though and suspect from the noise that this might be a very tight crop of a larger original? it also lacks a focal point somehwere my eye is drawn. Naturally this might be the head but when I get there (being drawn by the arrow-shaped wake) I see a blurry shape underwater. 6

A Window View
by myfelix

Comment:
The trick with unusual viewpoint is to be able to see differently without dong contortions. I suspect this is an ordinary portrait view shot looking up at the facade of the building and then rotated through 90 deg. This just makes my head spin and me want to twist round to look at it. Thus a poor interpretation IMHO. However, it's a lovely subject and well taken. 5

The Prudential Building, Buffalo, NY
by lwkimages

Comment:
Beautifully composed and edited. A real treat. My one quibble is that the sky has obviously been darkened and this leaves an unatural look to the boundary between sky and building as if you've just airbrushed the whole sky black. Not having sight of the original it's difficult to judge. Anyway - good work 9.