Fall Scene
by jjbeguin

Comment:
This is just outstanding. I love the effect here done with the water reflection and just a whisp of fog. What a great eye. You are truly a master. (10)

Country Sunrise
by Brad

Comment:
I am just not a big fan of using post editing to "make" the picture. I like the idea some others had of using water reflections and shower glass to get the impressionist effect. I am sure that the original picture here was beautiful, but you can't tell because of the post editing.

Silence
by heida

Comment:
Heida, this picture is stunning! Two in a row, congratulations.
Vision is the difference between and average photogragher (like me, below average actually) and a real artist. Keep up the good work!

I had said some negative things to djtj, but edited it when I realized how new he was to the site, as my comments were about judging others when you yourself had not put your own work out to be judged. I hope that you get involved in the site and see why the site council(through much debate) decided to allow the members challenges to be post edited in this way. I think it was a good decision, as was the decision to leave the open challenge with the limited editing rules. Now we get to see the whole range of talents of the photograghers on this site, IMHO.
Anyway, enjoy the site, it is really an awesome one!


Message edited by author 2004-07-12 17:51:32.

Wondering...
by bruski

Comment:
I love the look here and the composition. I would have rated it higher if you could have gotten the face in focus a little better.

Someday.....
by geewhy

Comment:
Great shot, exactly fit the challenge. Well posed and with great color and clarity.

Blond light
by Louison

Comment:
This shot surprised me, a perfect example of why not to judge on the thumbnail. The thumbnail looked out of focus, but the shot is crisp and soft and quite lovely. 8

Veronique
by sahko

Comment:
Very well posed and shot. Nice color and clarity. 9

Princess
by Sonifo

Comment:
Absolute perfection! 10

My city by the sea
by heida

Comment:
Absolutely stunning, definately a ribbon winner in my book. This picture really stands out! (10)

Oak Bay, British Columbia
by ccraft

Comment:
I wish I lived there!!