Eyes
by P-A-U-L

Comment:
A bit too saturated - the red sweater takes away the focus, and the vien between the eyes stands out. Also could have used a bit noise reduction.

Confidante
by neenee1999

Comment:
Too much smoothing of the skin, in my opinion. Great detail in the eyes.

5 Star
by dswann

Comment:
Very lovely colours. I think the crop is a bit too tight (did lens lens go wider?) Alternatively, you could have cropped the plant on the left, the chair on the right, and the window in the ceiling a bit different.

This will score well, though. Congratulations :)

Focus
by ShutterRev

Comment:
Nice DOF and friendly dog :)

However, I don't think the image needed any HDR editing. And - and this is a very personal opinion, I know - pets are extremely uninteresting. I get no story from the photograph.

I think the crop is a bit too tight at the top and left side.

Surf & Light
by Bear_Music

Comment:
Beautiful colour in the waves. Still, I think B&W would look awesome here. The colour of the vegetation is a bit bland.

In her last days
by wetland

Comment:
Nice composition and I love the barn.

The purple aura at the edges it a bit too much, and the sky in uninteresting.

I feel like the shutter speed is too long to make the water crisp, yet too short to make it dreamy. It might be due to the HDR process. Is this one (i.e. split into -2,0,+2 in PP) or more exposures merged?

Lastly, I think HDR should be applied in situations where it adds to the image - I am pretty sure that you could fit the histogram in one exposure.

There's always a child in everyone
by Alex_Petrini

Comment:
Nice concept. A tilt-shift lens would have made the building more appealing. Why are those lenses so expensive? :/

November Mist, Daybreak
by Bear_Music

Comment:
This is a lovely photo, where the grain - as one of the few in this challenge - actually adds to the overall mood of the photo. If I could choose, the two "boys" should have been left out.

3
by RKT

Comment:
What? Sorry didn't mean to comment in the first place... Anyway, now that I'm at it:

Lovely colors, would have liked a tad vignette. The grain does not add to the impact of the photo IMO - no drama here :) Nice enough shot, though.

Autumn Tapestry
by CNovack

Comment:
Congrats on the red. While the photograph is lovely, the warning sign is kind of annoying :)