Parking Lot
by dahved

Comment:
I think you met the challenge, but the main subject is so uninteresting that you might as well have just left it out. Just my opinion and others might score it higher.

Johnny Guitar
by pawdrix

Comment:
A very "telling" picture. The subject might be too large for this challenge to get many big votes, but it is a great photo. If the challenge were "Candid" I would give a definite 10, but in this one 6.

1 / 35
by virtuamike

Comment:
With the direct angle of your shot the grid work in the glass has a dizzying effect on this viewer. I might suggest that you take it from different angles to see what the effects might be. You meet the challenge well, but it lacks much interest as is.

tool1
by zelnicki

Comment:
IMO the tool takes up too much of the frame for this challenge. Also it lacks the WOW factor of a great photo. That is probably the hardest thing to capture in a photograph. Keep shooting, it will get better.

Boats on the Mist
by MAK

Comment:
Right on for the challenge. I can't say I like the frame though, it seems a little much, maybe just black.

Civil War Cannon - Will the smoke ever clear?
by glad2badad

Comment:
Your composition is, so right, that it is almost cliche. Nice job there. On my monitor it has a quite green cast, even in the clouds. If you did thid intentionally,okay, but I don't care for it.

hand-elarbra
by barbaraanne

Comment:
Nice play on words in your title. I am amazed when I see someone exert so much effort and time on a picture and then blunder when spelling their title. I think it should be (Handelabra) , Enough of that! Nice job with a difficult subject, the flame is still a bit bright, and there is a light spot almost in the center of the frame that distracts. This might just be the difference in monitors though. Good job.

Morning Workout
by rmtm333

Comment:
My eyes went immediately went to horse and cart and flowered field.. Great job. The subject is very small, yet shows a fair amount of detail. I gotta go a ten here!

Standing Strong
by beamsclan

Comment:
This looks quite a bit over processed on my monitor, and the sky overpowers your intended subject. IMO anyway.

Surrounded by Beauty
by JScho

Comment:
This is a wonderful shot, however I seem to be getting pulled into the detail of the feathers more than the smaller head area. A fasinating composition and presentation nonetheless.