A River Runs Through It
by channeled

Comment by robsmith:
My voting criteria for this challenge are:

1. Did you capture a scene from the movie (as the challenge brief states) or did you enter a picture and fit a title to it.
2. How close a rendition is your image to the movie.
3. How does the image stand up in its own right.

In this case:

1. Yes, this scene will be familiar to people who have either seen the film or the advertising
2. This is obviously your own interpretation of the scene and actually quite true to the movie
3. The picture is very strong in its own right. The darker detail in the trees has been captured without losing the highlights in the river. On close inspection there appears to be some jpeg artifacts in the reflections but this doesn't distract greatly.

Overall a very good picture which both meets the challenge and stands up in its own right. 8

A River Runs Through It
by channeled

Comment by vjoz:
Well, I'm not sure what Movie this is, but you wont get a lower score from my 'cos of my ignorance :)

this is a good place to take a shot, the bend in the river makes a perfect background...

All I see is that it is maybe a bit to compressed, you know that images can be 150kb when submitted, that would have given you a lot more quality...

good luck in the challange

A River Runs Through It
by channeled

Comment by silverleaf:
It was great how you caught the two boys. I liked how you had the older boy actively fishing while the younger one was almost observing and learning

A River Runs Through It
by channeled

Comment by karmat:
Oh my gosh. I thought for sure I had chosen a movie other people wouldn't think of. Who would have guessed fly fishing was so popular. I like the composition and colors in this one.