Sundown in December
by Mona

Comment:
It is very nice, but not very memorable. It looks like there's a bench out on the spit of land? Perhaps working that into the composition might give it more of a story? -6-

Plasma Ball
by Wildpurple

Comment:
Nicely done, but I think a bit of space around it would look better. The crop seems tight and strangely uneven. Not centered, but not that off center, either.

Wired
by ELLIPS

Comment:
I like the idea and the find, but it doesn't work for me. The shadow takes up so much and is a little interesting, but doesn't hold my interest for long. And lining the wall up on the edge but having it slightly tilted feels off. Perhaps a different crop or tilting it even more?

Stark
by wolf

Comment:
The textures and the eye are wonderful, but the crop is just too distracting, imo. Even if you cropped part of the nose off, I think it would look better than having it so tight.

Lost In Your Eyes
by IAmEliKatz

Comment:
-9- from me. Can’t think of anything to improve it. You captured a story that’s intriguing and did it beautifully. -9-

Grasshopper with Droplets
by roz

Comment:
Amazing shot because of the droplets. So clean and beautiful. Don’t really have any suggestions. At first I thought a portrait crop, but I like the oof leading lines of the leaves to the left. Then I thought, place him more to the right, not centered, but I like it this way. So can’t think of anything to make it better. -9-

Abandoned Piano
by GinaRothfels

Comment:
I didn’t even notice it was a piano when I voted. Obviously people will think the cat shouldn’t be behind the scroll. The setup isn’t perfect, but it was an intriguing story. I gave it a 9 for the find and the story. Now that I see it’s a piano, it seems like maybe some more space at the top? It seems a little crowded up there. -9-

Still Life in Pastel
by kasaba

Comment:
Love the softness and editing on this. Really really beautiful. 9 from me. The only thing I’d think about changing is the crop. It seems like more space on the left would be good. Since the lily and the bottle that’s laying down point to the left, it feels like it could use a little more breathing room. Plus the extra space at the top seems to need some balancing. Really beautiful. -9-

My Gym
by clickodak

Comment:
This was a 9 from me because of the lighting. The lighting is really well done. I don’t even have any suggestions. I’d be curious what the whole bike would look like, but then I think you’d lose the great details on the handlebar tape. Beautifully done!

B O O !
by grahamgator

Comment:
drat drat drat!! I forgot to vote on this one. I don't understand how this didn't do spectacularly well. I think it's brilliant. I'm looking at it on my phone, so it may change looking at it on my monitor. But I absolutely love it. It would have been a 10 from me. I can hardly wait to see it on a larger screen.